I love Brigid Lowry. I discovered
her when I read Juicy Writing, my
favorite non-fiction book of writing tips. Everything I’ve read by her has the
same entrancing almost-poetical feel. She has a trick of spinning words, using
them in unique ways, and creating a magical ambience that’s completely
different from anything else I’ve ever read. Her distinctive turn of phrase may
have something to do with the fact that she’s Australian, so even though her
books are English, the unique phraseology almost seems like a foreign language.
But the frustrating thing is that because she’s Australian and my local library
is not exactly international in scope, they have hardly any of them. But they
had this one, and I jumped on it like a four-footed animal.
As usual, I enjoyed the author’s
conversational tone, and the little world she builds over the course of a book.
The little lists and creative sidenotes were classic Lowry, and gave a great
flavor to the story. But I didn’t like this book as much as some of the others.
Georgia is self-centered,
melodramatic, rude, hypercritical and hyper-sensitive. She constantly assumes
the worst of those she comes into contact with. And quite often things that absolutely
devastate her aren’t that big of a deal. Maybe it’s meant to be endearing, but
she really just seems like a brat. She lectures her mother, mentally and verbally. She’s the kind of girl
you’d either (wait for it) hate or love. Ahem. Sorry. Had to.
The relationship between her and
her best friend was sad to me. The book only covered the period of time during
which they’re growing apart, so I never felt like they actually were best friends. They spend time
together, and talk together, but they also put self first and rarely share life
with each other. Maybe if I’d believed they really were best friends it
would’ve been more bittersweet watching them grow apart, instead of just
depressing.
I don’t regret reading this book,
but that’s about the best I can say. Maybe if I was younger I would’ve enjoyed
it more, but the cursing keeps me from recommending it to a younger audience
that might appreciate it more. If you already like Brigid Lowry, it’s worth
reading just because. But if you want a better sample of her work or are
looking for a fun read, I’d pass this one by.
I've never read any of her books, but I have a hard time with annoying teenagers. I don't mind teen adventure stories or such, but ones where they're just whining are no fun. It sounds like she is being real to a lot of teens' lives cause that is when we are all most annoying and often lose our best friends through selfishness, but that doesn't make it fun or rewarding to read about.
ReplyDeleteThat's rather how I felt. I don't doubt the accuracy of it, but sometimes accuracy to the ugly parts of life (particularly in adolescence) is not really what teen books should be focusing on.
Delete